OTP, HOTP, and TOTP Explained: The Complete Guide to One-Time Passwords

For enhanced security of customers, businesses need to opt for OTP (One-time Password). Be it a transaction, account update, or any other serious task that could risk the user's identity, data, money, etc.

With OTP, it becomes easier to identify the users. When the secret code is entered, it ensures only the authorized person is involved in the process.

Over time, OTP has become more advanced. Now, we have HOTP and TOTP variants. Let's dive into the details of these and see which one is the right choice for your business.

Part 1. What is OTP: The Foundation of Modern Authentication

One-Time Passwords represent a quantum leap in authentication security, addressing critical vulnerabilities inherent in traditional password systems. At their core, OTPs are dynamically generated credentials valid for only a single authentication session or a brief time window. This temporary nature fundamentally changes the security equation - even if a malicious actor intercepts an OTP, it becomes worthless almost immediately.

The implementation of OTP systems varies across industries and use cases. In banking, you'll frequently encounter SMS-delivered OTPs for transaction verification, while enterprise environments often rely on dedicated hardware tokens or authenticator apps. The healthcare sector has adopted OTP solutions to protect sensitive patient data, complying with strict regulations like HIPAA. Even social media platforms now offer OTP-based two-factor authentication (2FA) to safeguard user accounts.

However, not all OTP delivery methods are equally secure. SMS-based OTPs, while convenient, have become increasingly vulnerable to sophisticated attacks like SIM swapping and SS7 protocol exploits. More secure alternatives include:

• Authenticator applications (Google Authenticator, Microsoft Authenticator)
• Hardware security tokens (YubiKey, RSA SecurID)
• Push notification-based approvals
• Biometric verification systems

The cryptographic foundation of OTP systems ensures that each password generation is mathematically unique and unpredictable. Advanced implementations may use algorithms like SHA-256 or SHA-3 instead of the original SHA-1, providing stronger protection against brute-force attacks. As cyber threats evolve, so too do OTP technologies, with new innovations like quantum-resistant algorithms beginning to emerge.

Part 2. What is HOTP: The Counter-Based Authentication Workhorse

HMAC-Based One-Time Password (HOTP) represents the first major evolution in OTP technology, introducing a counter-based system that revolutionized authentication security. Developed as part of RFC 4226, HOTP provides a robust framework for generating one-time passwords without requiring continuous network connectivity, making it ideal for offline use cases.

HOTP Algorithm Explained: A Deep Dive into Cryptographic Mechanics

The HOTP generation process is an elegant combination of cryptographic principles and practical engineering. At its heart lies the HMAC (Hash-Based Message Authentication Code) algorithm, which creates a unique fingerprint from two essential components: a secret key known only to the authentication server and client device, and an incrementing counter value that changes with each OTP generation.

The technical process unfolds through several precise steps:

• Initialization: A shared secret key is securely distributed to both the authentication server and client device (like a hardware token or mobile app).
• Counter Synchronization: Both systems maintain an identical counter value, starting at 0 and incrementing with each OTP generation.
• HMAC Computation: The system calculates HMAC-SHA-1(SecretKey, Counter) to produce a 160-bit hash value.
• Dynamic Truncation: Using a sophisticated bit manipulation process, this hash is converted into a human-friendly 6-8 digit number.
• Presentation: The final OTP is displayed to the user for authentication.

A critical advantage of HOTP is its resilience in offline environments. Consider a bank employee accessing a secure financial system in a remote location without internet access. Their hardware token can generate valid HOTP codes regardless of connectivity because the synchronization depends only on the counter value, not real-time communication with a server.

However, this strength also introduces potential vulnerabilities. If a user generates multiple HOTP codes without using them (perhaps by pressing the token button multiple times), the counter on the token gets ahead of the server's counter. This desynchronization can lead to authentication failures, requiring manual resynchronization procedures that can be cumbersome for end-users.

Part 3. What is TOTP: The Time-Based Security Revolution

Time-Based One-Time Password (TOTP) systems represent a significant advancement over HOTP, addressing many of its practical limitations while introducing new security benefits. Defined in RFC 6238, TOTP replaces the incrementing counter with a time-based value, creating a more user-friendly and secure authentication experience.

TOTP Algorithm Explained: Precision Timing for Enhanced Security

TOTP's ingenious innovation lies in its use of time as the dynamic variable in password generation. The process begins with the same foundation as HOTP - a shared secret key between server and client - but instead of a counter, it uses the current Unix timestamp divided into fixed time intervals (typically 30 seconds).

The step-by-step generation process reveals why TOTP has become the preferred choice for most modern applications:

• Time Sampling: The system takes the current timestamp and divides it by the time step (e.g., 30 seconds), creating a time counter that changes periodically.
• HMAC Computation: Identical to HOTP, the system computes HMAC-SHA-1(SecretKey, TimeCounter).
• Truncation and Display: The same dynamic truncation method produces the final 6-8 digit code shown to the user.

The time-based approach solves several critical problems:

• Automatic Synchronization: No more counter mismatches - both systems just need reasonably accurate clocks (within ±30 seconds typically).
• Strict Time Limitation: Codes typically expire after 30-60 seconds, drastically reducing the window for potential misuse.
• Predictable Regeneration: Users know exactly when a new code will be generated, improving usability.

This architecture explains why TOTP has become ubiquitous in consumer applications. When you use Google Authenticator to log into your email or Microsoft Authenticator to access corporate resources, you're benefiting from TOTP's robust security model. The system's elegance lies in its simplicity - it requires no special hardware, just a smartphone with an authenticator app and a reasonably accurate clock.

Part 4. HOTP vs TOTP: Difference & Advantages

When evaluating one-time password systems, understanding the fundamental differences between HMAC-Based (HOTP) and Time-Based (TOTP) implementations is crucial for making informed security decisions. These protocols share the same cryptographic foundation but differ dramatically in operation and security implications.

HOTP vs TOTP Comparison Table

Generation Mechanism Comparison

The core distinction lies in how each system generates its dynamic value. HOTP uses a simple incrementing counter that advances with each OTP generation. This means every button press on a hardware token increases the counter by one. In contrast, TOTP calculates its dynamic value by taking the current Unix timestamp (number of seconds since January 1, 1970) and dividing it by a time step (usually 30 seconds).

Synchronization Requirements

HOTP's counter-based approach creates potential synchronization challenges. If a user generates five codes but only uses the third one, the server and client counters become mismatched by two positions. This requires administrative intervention to resynchronize, often through a sequence of valid codes.

TOTP eliminates this problem entirely by relying on time, which naturally synchronizes across systems. As long as the client and server clocks are reasonably aligned (usually within ±30 seconds), no manual intervention is needed. This makes TOTP significantly more manageable in large-scale deployments.

Security Analysis: Advantages and Limitations

1 HOTP Security Profile

- Advantages:

• Offline Reliability: Perfect for environments without constant network access
• Predictable Generation: No reliance on external time sources
• Emergency Access: Unused codes remain valid indefinitely

- Limitations:

• Counter Desynchronization: Mismatches require manual reset procedures
• Extended Attack Window: Intercepted codes remain valid until used
• Phishing Vulnerability: Users can't distinguish between current/old codes

2 TOTP Security Enhancements

- Critical Advantages:

• Temporal Limitations: The 30-second validity window dramatically reduces attack opportunities
• Automatic Expiry: Eliminates stale code risks
• Phishing Resistance: Even if a user accidentally discloses a code, it expires quickly
• No Counter Management: Removes an entire category of support issues

- Implementation Considerations:

• Requires reliable time synchronization
• Time drift can cause issues in air-gapped systems
• Less suitable for environments where immediate network access isn't guaranteed

Future Evolution and Hybrid Approaches

Modern security systems increasingly combine both technologies's strengths:

• Fallback Mechanisms: TOTP for regular access with HOTP backup codes
• Step-Up Authentication: HOTP for high-value transactions after TOTP login
• Adaptive Systems: Using TOTP normally but switching to HOTP when offline

Emerging standards like OCRA (OATH Challenge-Response Algorithm) build on these foundations while addressing their limitations. The FIDO Alliance's work on passwordless authentication may eventually supersede both, but OTP systems will remain critical for legacy support and specific use cases.

Part 5. Why EngageLab is a Smart Choice for TOTP Authentication?

Businesses need a reliable option for sending OTPs, or specifically TOTPs. It should be sent with secrecy and at the right time.

EngageLab is an excellent option for sending TOTPs. It is a powerful multi-channel marketing platform that helps you reach your users through App Push, Web Push, SMS, Email, WhatsApp, and OTP—all in one place. Whether you're sending promotions or verifying users, EngageLab makes it easy to connect at the right time, on the right channel.

EngageLab's OTP API is built with strong security to protect against attacks and keep user data safe. It's designed for businesses of any size and can scale easily as you grow.

The service complies with global and regional regulations, covers over 200 countries and regions.

Conclusion

OTP is the need of the hour. Both HOTP and TOTP have their advantages and disadvantages, but TOTP is widely used because it's more secure. We have compared both to help users pick the right one according to their needs. For reliable TOTP delivery, EngageLab is an excellent option. It's a fast, scalable, and customizable solution to send TOTPs worldwide. Contact us today and share your requirements for an ideal TOTP solution.

Start For Free